Bismillah.
There is a lengthy series on personal financing (financing your education in a halal fashion) on Muslim Matters. It’s quite interesting to read.
There is a bit of a discussion first of all about whether it’s really even necessary to go to college or university. Well, I won’t debate that, but let me at least give you the real cost of education. In economics they call this “opportunity cost”. When you go to university for 3 or 4 years, that means you are losing that income. Say an entry level job with absolutely no post-highschool diploma education you can make $30,000 to $40,000. For the sake of argument, lets say you are more competent and you can get a decent job at $40,000 (say telemarketing, sales, construction, or whatever). You have to factor this into the cost of your education.
So really your education comes at a cost of 4 years of lost income or $160,000. Now, from a strictly financial perspective, you have to ask yourself, am I going to make up that $160,000 over my lifetime because I have a degree? That is a long discussion and I won’t get into it. But to summarize, it depends and that’s what you need to think about.
Lets say you have now decided you want to go to university. Great. But how to finance it.. ?? ??
- First of all you have to realize the seriousness of riba. Interest (paying it or receiving it) is one form of riba. So thats the first step.
- Second of all, you have to make sincere intention to avoid it at any costs and try your utmost to do this.
- This might require a lot of personal sacrifice. This starts with living frugally (i.e. living simple. No expensive cell phones, avoid eating out, try to get stuff used instead of brand new, and so on)
- Enrol in a CO-OP program (such as University of Waterloo Computer Science), and be practical about which programs lead to $$$. This might sound harsh but it’s good advice from a good brother and friend of mine. Alternatively you work part-time in the evenings or on weekends.
- Lastly, place your trust in Allah. After you did all that, you place your trust in Allah and leave it to him
Now lets say you did all of the above (or maybe its too late and you are about to graduate) and you need to pay off your loan without paying interest? Well if you have either personal loans from family members or friends and they are not interest bearing, great, this doesn’t apply to you. Otherwise, here is what you can do.
As a background note, before I explain, I live in Canada and received OSAP (Ontario Student Assistance Program which is basically an interest-free loan for the duration of your studies) but as soon as you graduate interest starts accumulating immediately. Update: Someone emailed me to ask if this is halal. I don’t think its halal to sign such a contract, please read the muslimmatters blog for a similar explanation about credit cards and why it’s best to avoid them.
How I personally avoided interest on my entire loan.
- Gather a list of all your friends and family members who might be able to help you with your loan. Be creative, your list should include the imam of the masjid you attend, the sheikh teaching the last seminar you attended, and so on.
- Contact them and ask them for assistance. Mention to them that you are in a difficult situation, maybe they were also in a similar situation and needed help. One brother who gave me some money as a loan mentioned that he was also in a similar situation and someone helped him, so he told himself that if ever someone asks him for help with student loans he will give him the money for that. The easiest way is to email them and ask them. I would recommend a personal email. Here is a draft:
Dear So and So
Assalam alaikum wa rahmatullah
I am in the final year of my university program at UofXYZ.
I am about to graduate and land my first job inshaAllah. The program I have studied in has given me an excellent background in this field and I feel confident about landing my first job shortly. I hope you can assist me so that I can avoid paying interest on my loans. I am looking for a 2-4 year loan that will be paid back entirely at the end of the term or sooner if required. JazakAllahu Khaira.
Your nameAs an exercise, you can look up a few hadith and ayah on the reward of lending loans and the seriousness of riba.
By the way, It helps if you already have a job offer. It also helps if you are well known in the community (i.e. go to the masjid regularly, and so on).
Here is how it worked out for me.
- An older brother (doctor) lent me $1000
- A university friend (graduated before me) $500
- My paternal uncle $1500
- A close friend who was graduated and working $500
- Another friend who lived with me at one time and graduated before me $2500
-
My brother undisclosed amount
- A brother who I only knew online but emailed him for help (lived in USA) $1000
- Another brother whom I only met once before in the masjid – approximately $29000
Now you might be wondering why someone I met only once would lend me so much money? The simple reason is for the sake of Allah. He obviously did some reference checks on me from friends and others. The funny thing is I just asked him for $1000 but due to some circumstance I mentioned that I actually needed more and then he offered to lend me whatever was remaining (asked me to pay him back within 2 years if possible).
The surprising thing is that people I thought who had money didn’t, and where I least expected it, thats where it came from.
As a last note, if you are trying your best but not succeeding, keep in mind, its the effort that counts, not the result. Effort from you, results from Allah. Now sleep soundly knowing that you did whatever you could to please Allah.
Rejoice!
(listen)
#1 by aarij on December 3, 2008 - 7:08 pm
Quote
Ma sha Allah, what an awesome article!
#2 by omar on December 3, 2008 - 7:14 pm
Quote
One additional way to delay OSAP payments and interest is by maintaining full-time student status. So for example, you might be able to work full-time while taking 3 cheap, easy courses at a community college which enable you to have full-time student status and delay your OSAP payments while you try to save money to pay off your loan.
#3 by Abdullah on December 3, 2008 - 7:19 pm
Quote
Omar, that seems like a very expensive way to maintain interest free status
#4 by Uzair on December 3, 2008 - 7:20 pm
Quote
Mashallah, very encouraging article for all to read! Jazakallah khair for sharing your story and struggles for us to learn and take example from.
#5 by Imtiyaz Ahmed on December 3, 2008 - 7:22 pm
Quote
A couple of more options that everybody needs to consider are the following:
1. Maintain good marks in school especially your last 2 years
2. Apply for interest relief if you know you are not going to land a job immediately after graduation like me – a lot of students are not aware of this so there is no need to enroll in full time school and endure more debt. The other option is to be self-employed and live with your parents until you get married, better yet get married your interest relief is easier because now your max income per month goes up because you have to support your spouse also.
3. Loan forgiveness – I had $36,000 in OSAP & Federal Student loans when I graduated in total and $16,000 was forgiven by the government.
#6 by Uzair on December 3, 2008 - 7:27 pm
Quote
FYI…there’s still one aspect that’s being overlooked here: The government is actually paying interest on your behalf while you are in school. In addition, interest-relief also involves the government paying interest on your behalf as well. Although it’s not as serious as you paying the interest yourself, interest is still being paid in your name for the money that was loaned out. I think another even better option for people to explore is to try to borrow money from people before you start a semester. However, if that is not possible, then I guess this strategy is the next best option.
#7 by omar on December 3, 2008 - 7:30 pm
Quote
It may be expensive, but for many people it will be the only option. Its not easy to get a loan from people. One can also turn it into a positive…you can take courses which offer you benefit either in your career or in other aspects of life. Also, you might be able to find college courses for $300 or so, so you pay $900 for 4 months while saving interest payments for 4 months so its not that bad.
#8 by Abdullah on December 3, 2008 - 7:31 pm
Quote
There is one more problem with the “interest relief” OSAP program. That is that you have to pay interest for 6 months before you qualify..
Thats a huge bummer. And on top of that, if I remember correctly, it keeps expiring every few years and you have to renew it. So I ruled out that option as viable. Disclaimer: They may have changed their policies now.
#9 by omar on December 3, 2008 - 7:35 pm
Quote
*before* anybody follows my backup suggestion, they should verify for themselves if it will infact delay their OSAP interest, if they will have full-times status, etc.
#10 by AbDELlah on December 4, 2008 - 2:02 am
Quote
You also have to repay OSAP over 14 years (if you can’t repay it sooner of course) which means that you’ll end up paying 3 or 4 times your initial loan in interest. So, regardless of “reba” why would you pay 3 or 4 times your initial loan.
Thanks.
#11 by Mrs Sarah Nicole on August 17, 2009 - 3:58 pm
Quote
FNANCIAL* * LOAN OFFER **APPLY **NOW*
Hello i am Mrs Sarah Nicole ,We loan funds out to individuals in need of financial assistance,
that have a bad credit or in need of money to pay bills,to invest on
business.I want to use this medium to inform you that we render
reliable and beneficiary assistance as be glad to offer you a
loan email : sarah.loancompany26@gmail.com
*INFORMATION NEEDED FROM YOU AS A BORROWER..*
Full Name:………
Country:……
State:……
City:…….
zsw2Sex:……..
Age:……
Occupation:…………
Amount needed as loan:………
phone Number:………..
Monthly Income:………….
Purpose For the Loan:…….
Duration To Pay Back The Loan:……
Home Address:…. …
These are the Information your are to provide For Application okay.
#12 by Adil on December 4, 2008 - 6:23 am
Quote
Another tip that might help that I learned: Its from a brother who used to be a manager at National Student Loans. Call National Student Loans and tell them you cannot pay this amount for whatever reason(Please don’t say what to say or how to say, that’s up to you). Be very stubborn, persistent and adamant about this. They usually start to bargain how much can you pay and differ as much as they can. This is done quite regularly. Call again perhaps they may further reduce your loans more. Doesn’t mean it will work, just may help,inshallah
#13 by slave of allah on December 4, 2008 - 7:52 pm
Quote
i heard there are couple of brothers working in interest free loan idea in gta..inshallah tere should be something coming up soon
#14 by Anonymous on December 4, 2008 - 9:51 pm
Quote
How long did it take you to pay off the entire balance?
#15 by Abdullah on December 4, 2008 - 10:00 pm
Quote
Let’s just say I’m still working on it…
#16 by QK on December 6, 2008 - 12:56 pm
Quote
Question: Anyone who has had the liberty of getting help to pay off their loans believe it is their duty to help their actual brothers or sisters with their loan any way they can when it is their turn? It is easy to worry about yourself, but what about worrying about your immediate brothers in the same manner.
Pingback: Open Thread December 7th ‘08 | MuslimMatters.org
#17 by abu abdAllah, the Houstonian on December 7, 2008 - 12:56 pm
Quote
bismillah. as salamu alaykum. i followed the MM link to this article, and think it has much good advice, mashaAllah.
in the US, too many legislators think increasing loan limits for student loans will benefit students. so now there are US students who take as much as $40,000 per year as undergrads. if they also do three years of grad school, they will be looking at $280,000 of debt when they finish. it’s insanity.
even more perverse is that increasing “what students can pay” encourages colleges and universities to max out what they charge students. so the cost of education — the portion passed on to students — just keeps rising. and eventually loan limits will rise again…
may Allah protect us all from such poor decision-making, and may He guide us and our communities to what is better.
#18 by Imran Khan on January 1, 2009 - 3:46 pm
Quote
Assalamaliakoom
“After reading this I don’t have word to say…Masha Allah”
#19 by Sara Saqib on January 7, 2009 - 2:01 am
Quote
nice article
MAY BE another way of delaying the OSAP payment is leaving out a couple of courses from your degree program until you earn enough money to pay the loan back. i guess that would work.. not sure though
#20 by Mustafa on February 19, 2009 - 5:58 pm
Quote
Asalmu Alaikum,
I was just looking at how much money I owe to the goverment and was thinking how I am going to pay all this amount, but after reading your article it gives me something to think about.
Jazak allahu Kiran,
Mustafa
#21 by Muhammad on March 3, 2009 - 9:06 am
Quote
AOA,
I am not trying to be negative here but did you verify before borrowing money from your friends/brother; whether they are debt free (no loan, no mortgage whatsoever…) if not; then in my opinion whats the gain…? Someone still paying the Riba on the money you borrowed……
May Allaha Bless us all…
#22 by Abdullah on March 3, 2009 - 4:30 pm
Quote
Muhammad, Lol of course they wouldn’t put themselves into riba to get me out of it LOL
That would be kinda silly now…
Ameen to your dua.
#23 by Mujju on March 27, 2009 - 4:38 am
Quote
Assalamualaikum,
Inshallah, I’ll be graduating this year, i.e. in about a months time. I have roughly $16,000 of OSAP (unfortunately).
But, Alhamdulillah, I have an offer of employment and will be starting full time work in June.
I wish to follow your advice and borrow from Muslim brothers/sisters and pay my OSAP back immediately, i.e. next month. And pay my (now interest-free loan) back over the coming year(s).
Can you please help me make this happen. Alhamdulillah, you seem to have a lot of good contacts.
I pray Allah swt protects us from our own shortcomings in not having a support structure already in place that helps students like myself stay away from one of the greatest sins in Islam.
Abdullah, is it okay if I ask people to post here if they are willing to help me?
Jazakallahukhairan katheeran.
#24 by uzma on June 7, 2009 - 6:34 am
Quote
aslaamu alaikum wrwb
mashAllah amazing article..and amazing advice. jazakAllah khair.
can i plz request all of u to make dua for me.
jazakAllah
waslaam
#25 by Umar on September 17, 2009 - 5:21 am
Quote
Asalam Alaykoom
I made a huge mistake in taking out student loans early on in my college career. I was not very knowledgeable in the deen and was unaware of the seriousness of riba..
Now I am finishing my Master’s Degree in the US and have nearly $50 K in student loads, subhanallah.. I am currently seriously thinking of ways in which I can do this, and I make dua to Allah to make it easy for me..
My point is, don’t get into loans in the first place. I had a friend who worked the night shift at UPS his entire undergrad time, and they paid tuition for him. If you work hard, it can be done. I regret having taken OSAP in the first place, and am now warning other brothers against it.
May Allah make it easy for us and guide us all.
#26 by Asim on October 22, 2009 - 10:23 am
Quote
Asalamualaikum
I’m also one of those who have shouldered the burden. I’ve $18369 to pay. I have no job as of now. I have been trying my best to make arrangements…but there doesn’t seem to be any light. On Allah alone do i depend…for he is the best of those who can help!
#27 by Sister on January 10, 2010 - 10:51 pm
Quote
Jazakillahu kheirun for this article. Alhamdulillah I don’t plan on taking student loans insha Allah, but I know some people who are extremely close to me that have taken some (I don’t think they knew much about it), and I was trying to find some solution. Alhamdulillah! May Allah reward you GREATLY with the best of the dunya and the akhira and may He help everyone here and all those Muslims who are in these situations. Ameen.
We desperately need some sort of system in place to help Muslim students to pay for their education. May Allah give us one. Ameen.
#28 by Youssef on February 8, 2010 - 10:57 pm
Quote
Jazakoum allah khairan for this nice article.